Confirmation

Here’s a little nugget I stumbled across in a book on wargames. Georg Leopold von Reiswitz, the man who made the original wargame table for Friedrich Wilhelm III, and who also developed the rules in concert with other military staff.  He committed suicide for professional reasons* and his son later developed the rules further.  Anyway the interesting thing is:

A year after his death [i.e., 1828], a supplement** appeared that built on Reiswitz’s war game instruction manual without a single mention of it or him. Among the innovations of the supplement were the exceptional roll of the dice and an emergency die. If an improbable exceptional roll succeeded, the emergency die decided whether the exception took effect.  Because if the point was “not to exclude any case that is possible in war, even so improbable a case, the game must also permit exceptions to the rule that must, however, have their own rules in turn.”–War games : a history of war on paper / Philipp von Hilgers; translated by Ross Benjamin.  MIT Press, c2012.

So as early as 1828 game designers had the idea of ‘confirming’ improbable events.  This reminded me of ‘confirming’ criticals in WotC D&D.  I had no idea this rule had such a long pedigree.

Actually, the talk of “exceptions to the rule” “hav[ing] their own rules in turn” is pretty much a thumbnail sketch of 3rd edition as I understand it.  I’m beginning to wonder: is the divide between ‘old school’ and ‘new school’ D&D really a divide between which of the roots of D&D is more important (old school perhaps preferring the free-form Braunstein and new school hearkening back more towards the Prussian Kriegspiel)?  Maybe the influence of MMOs and collectible card games that old school edition warriors bemoan is less essnetial to WotC D&D than the echoes of Kriegspielers…

———————–
*That is, not over the game, but because his superiors passed him for promotion and gave him crummy assignments.  I will try to use the phrase “committed suicide for professional reasons” more though, it makes me smile.

**The anonymous supplement mentioned is cited as: “Supplement zu den bisherigen Kriegspiel-Regeln.” Zeitschrift für Kunst, Wissenschaft, und Geschichte des Krieges 13(4): 68-105. 1828.

About these ads
Published in: on December 22, 2012 at 2:16 pm  Comments (5)  
Tags: , , ,

The URI to TrackBack this entry is: http://mikemonaco.wordpress.com/2012/12/22/confirmation/trackback/

RSS feed for comments on this post.

5 CommentsLeave a comment

  1. I also love the term ‘emergency die’. But I’d never want to implement somethingl ike what they’re talking about in the supplement — it would be as if you let the players roll the d30 of awesomeness and then have to ‘confirm’ the results with anonther roll. I suppose it would be a way to integrate d30s or awesome points or whatever into a more sober, realistic game.

  2. Interesting stuff! It seems to me, though, that if you need another die roll to confirm whether or not an improbable event specified by the dice actually occurs, then the (im)probability has not been correctly determined in the first place. Maybe this is a point in favour of d100 systems, where a finer grain of probability (e.g., the 1% chance) is built in. On the other hand, I suppose rolling d100 is effectively the same as rolling 1d10 and then rolling another 1d10 “emergency die”. Hmmm… *wanders off, scratching head*

    • Yes, the Kriegspielers were presumably using all d6s. I remember some older games from the 70s or early 80s used 2 d6s as a sort of % — ranging 11-66! I think Car Wars may have had some tables like that.

      • TOON definitely did.

  3. I think that whether a “confirmation” die is justified is a function of how exceptional the “special occurrence” would be, and whether you want the likelihood of it to be a constant. I first encountered the idea in the board wargame “Squad Leader” (technically in the “Cross of Iron” supplement), where a natural “2″ on 2 dice when firing ordnance at a tank means a possible “critical hit” with almost certain armor penetration and lethality. The confirmation roll is a single die roll of half the original to-hit roll or less.

    I’ve used a similar confirmation roll for critical hits in d20 based systems — A natural 20 (assuming it’s sufficient to hit) means a possible critical hit. The die is rolled again, and any roll that would normally hit the target (with all applicable modifiers) confirms the hit as critical. A “miss” on the qualifying die roll means the “20″ is merely a normal hit. I’ve heard criticism of this as overly complicated, but I don’t find a second die roll all that burdensome, and I like that it keeps critical hits from becoming more proportionally common against more difficult targets.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

2 Warps to Neptune

Down here it's our time. It's our time down here.

300 stories

A one-year mission to produce 300 stories in 300 words (or less)

Role Play Craft

Crafting ideas, options, and modules for your role playing campaign.

Cirsova

An encyclopedia of the Cirsovan empire, thoughts on Gaming, Music and more.

childoftheisland

Blog of writer Bia Helvetti

Taking Games Seriously

Because Fantasy without Philosophy is Garbage

The Rambling Roleplayer

I play roleplaying games and sometimes I write stuff about them.

The History Blog

History fetish? What history fetish?

Sheppard's Crook

The occasional blog of a closet would -be wargamer and modeller

10 Bad Habits

An idle mind is the devil's wood shed.

The Weekly Sift

making sense of the news one week at a time

HUGE RUINED PILE

A vast castle built by generations of mad wizards and insane geniuses.

inthecitiesdotcom

Just another WordPress.com site

Bunker Club 55

Another Dump of Stuff for your RPGs, D&D, Microlite 20, OSR

Lost in Time

"What happened to Claw Carver?"

chieflyill

gaming, graphics, and genrefication

Stuffed Crocodile

Mazes, Martians, Mead

Go Make Me a Sandwich

(how not to sell games to women)

Metropollywog

Role-Playing Games, Medieval History, Assorted Legends and Myths, and My Stupid Life.

pipeandscotchdm

Tabletop gaming, Dungeon-Mastering, pipesmoking, and single malts

PostGygaxian

The only completely consistent rationale for these restrictions is to say that they are necessary for the sake of game balance; the gods have so decreed it. But that is not an answer that satisfies the mind. page 8, Dragon 78

WordPress.com News

The latest news on WordPress.com and the WordPress community.

KEEP ROLLIN SIXES

Tales from South Zierden Alley

Wrathofzombie's Blog

A blog of Role-playing Dorkiness!

Atroll's Entertainment

A Troll's Account of Having Fun

Three Lil Pigs Painting

talking about painting miniatures for display and heritage figures

Architectural History At Sea

Richard Guy, Cornell

The Mule Abides

New York's Old School Dungeoneers

hotelnerd

This is the Venn Diagram of my Life

stefan poag

The Weird Fantasy Art of Stefan Poag

Dyson's Dodecahedron

Award Winning Dungeon Design

Reanimated Gaming

Rediscovering the world of gaming

Skulls in the Stars

The intersection of physics, optics, history and pulp fiction

Lost Pages

"The walls of the sandbox are patrolled by the Game Police"

Richard's Dystopian Pokeverse

Mostly Old-school RPG musings

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 188 other followers

%d bloggers like this: