In search of… a realistic combat system

One thing that seduced many players away from D&D back in the day (at least in my experience) was the combat system.  I used to frigging HATE AD&D‘s combat system. 1 minute rounds? d4+1 damage for a crossbow? Mid-level characters with 50 or more hit points, so that they take 10 or more sword wounds to kill?

“Don’t worry, I still have 6 hit points left!”

Of course I was occasionally persuaded that the hit points were just abstractions, as were the combat rounds and damage dice. It’s only a game, after all, right?  The DMG explains at some length that one minute rounds assume lots of parrying, dodging, etc. with one real opportunity to get in a hit.  But then weapons specialization, various stunts and maneuvers, and so on were added, each incrementally reducing the abstraction for me.

Rolemaster was the first serious alternative to AD&D that I remember playing. That game had higher hit point totals, but assumed, IIRC, that they represented actual damage (the skill “Body development” was the only way to gain hit points) and because a character had 30 or more h.p., bleeding could be assessed at a few points per round, and so on. Most importantly, a critical hit system made many, if not most, successful hits by weapons deadly. Many a Rolemaster character bled out from a severed femoral artery, or suffered shattered bones from a mace, as well as amputations, permanent nerve damage, and pretty much anything that could “really” happen when crazed orcs and dwarfs are swinging axes and swords.   A round was 6 or 10 seconds, I think, and armor actually made you harder to wound, not harder to hit. Good stuff but each frikking weapon had a separate combat matrix to roll on! (A falchion was one of my favorite weapons, just based on appearance and theory, and I was really glad to see that in RM they were among the best.) When we played RM,we had to assign one player the task of keeping track of the critical hit tables, another tracked the convoluted XP system, and another mapped.  It was a lot more like homework than gaming after a while.

A bit later my brother & I found GURPS, beginning with the first edition, and it had 1 second (!) rounds.  Weapon damage was closely tied to the wielder’s strength and whether the weapon chopped, crushed, or pierced the victim. With one-second rounds, unbalanced weapons (flails, axes, etc.) generally took a full second to recover after a swing, while swords did not, and while swords generally did a bit less damage than the hafted weapons, they were FAST. The mechanics seemed to effectively lead to realistic choices by players (yes, I’ll have all the armor I can carry if we’re going into battle, and give me a sword unless my opponent is very heavily armored, etc.). Shields were much more important than they had been in AD&D (a flat 5% bonus to defense) or Rolemaster (a 15 or 20 point bonus in a system where a percentile roll is modified by potentially huge numbers). In GURPS a shield can actively be used to block a blow, and passively may deflect a blow just by being in the way.

So GURPS won the realism laurel, and we really didn’t try anything new until 3rd , 3.5, and 4th edition D&D came about. All were more tactical than AD&D or Rolemaster (and about equal to GURPS) but they retained almost all the crazy artifacts of the abstract AD&D system, grafted onto a tactical movement system that only drew more attention to how unrealistic everything else is.

So I’ve actually come full circle, preferring the abstract combat of ODD or AD&D, even entertaining ODD‘s “all attacks do d6 damage” should I DM my own campaign.  Right now we play C&C and I am more than happy.

It turns out that realistic combat has the excellent advantage of making players more careful about when to fight, but also tends to make character death an almost unavoidable consequence of a few bad rolls.  More importantly, although I’ve played many serious gamers who love the challenge of mastering complex rules, no one I game with has the time for that, myself included.  Let me roll a d20 and be done with it, there’s a whole dungeon to explore!

(YMMV. For settings outside the D&D milieu, like Old West, Sci-Fi, Horror, and so on, more realistic and deadly combat systems have a place.  I can’t really imagine playing swashbuckling type games in anything but GURPS, for example.)

Published in: on January 20, 2010 at 1:43 am  Comments (2)  
Tags: , ,

The URI to TrackBack this entry is:

RSS feed for comments on this post.

2 CommentsLeave a comment

  1. You should try Melee for a realistic and quick combat system. It was created by Steve Jackson, sort of a forerunner of Gurps. The system was called The Fantasy Trip or TFT and consisted of Melee (the combat system), Wizard (Magic system) and In the Labyrinth (DMs guide). It went out of print back in the early 80’s but you might find a copy on Ebay or Amazon

    • I’ve always thought TFT looks like a great game. I wonder if Melee could be grafted onto D&D or Labyrinth Lord as the combat system…
      I think my brother actually owns Melee and I’ve looked at pdfs of the rest of the rules online; there was a guy in Texas who posted scans of everything on his web site, which of course is probably illegal; I don’t know if his site still exists.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Wayne's Books

Game Gallery ~ Photo Blog

Ann's Immaterium

Writing, gaming, miniature painting, physical culture, and other dark procrastinations.


Collecting, modelling, painting and wargaming in 28mm

Dragons Never Forget

What were we talking about again?

This Stuff is REALLY Cool

Young scholars enthusiastic to tell you about COOL RESEARCH STUFF

Fail Squad Games

Tabletop games and adventures

Chuck Wendig: Terribleminds

Hey Did You Know I Write Books

Save Vs. Dragon

"We are here on Earth to fart around. Don't let anybody tell you any different."--Kurt Vonnegut


Old School Roleplaying and related musings

Hobgoblin Orange

My return to the world of miniature figure painting and RPGs

The Book Reviews You Can Trust!

Dawn of the Lead

Miniature wargaming and the occasional zombie News

The latest news on and the WordPress community.


Miniature Motivation

Take On Rules

Jeremy Friesen - a poor soul consumed by gaming.

Age of Dusk

Roleplaying, reviews and associated paraphernalia.

Roll to Disbelieve

"We are here on Earth to fart around. Don't let anybody tell you any different."--Kurt Vonnegut

A Book of Creatures

A Complete Guide to Entities of Myth, Legend, and Folklore

Making the Past

Diary of an apprentice swordsmith

Ancient & Medieval Wargaming

Using De Bellis Antiquitatis, with the odd diversion...

Riffing Religion

Prophets should be mocked. I'm doing my part.


Magazine of Thrilling Adventure and Daring Suspense

2 Warps to Neptune

Surveying the Gen X landscape and the origins of geek

Dagger and Brush

Miniature painting, wargaming terrain tutorials, reviews, interviews and painting guides


A lair for gaming, sci-fi, comics, and other geekish pursuits.

I bought these adventure and review them so you don't have to.

9th Key Press

Maps, supplements, and inspiration for roleplaying games.

The Rambling Roleplayer Archives

This site is no longer being updated. Check out the new site at

The History Blog

History fetish? What history fetish?

Sheppard's Crook

The occasional blog of a closet would -be wargamer and modeller


A catch all of books, games, and sundry other interests

The Weekly Sift

making sense of the news one week at a time


Just another site

%d bloggers like this: